Web3: Assessing Decentralization of Blockchain Protocols

Decentralization is slowly becoming a key innovation in blockchain technology and one of the most important characteristics of web3 protocols. The path to decentralization is complex as it necessitates making significant adjustments and reevaluating the protocols’ basic operation.

Vis a vis Web3, decentralization emerges as a multifaceted concept composed of three integral types:

  • Technical
  • Economic
  • Legal decentralization

More or less, a collaborative symphony, where each class plays a distinct role.

Technical decentralization involves distributing a system’s infrastructure and essential components across multiple nodes or entities, preventing a single point of control. It’s akin to ensuring that the technical backbone of a network is dispersed rather than concentrated. Think of it as spreading out the behind-the-scenes tech responsibilities, like servers and databases, so that no single entity has complete control. 

Economic decentralization revolves around the distribution of financial power within a network. Imagine having your own financial playground. Economic decentralization allows you to manage your money independently, free from the influence of a central bank or financial authority. ​

Legal decentralization entails the distribution of governance and decision-making authority, ensuring that no single entity or jurisdiction has absolute control over the rules and policies of a system. There are mechanisms involved that let stakeholders influence how the protocol is governed. Picture a community meeting where everyone gets a vote.

It is a challenging task to decentralize a system that was designed to be centralized. How even do you begin? 

Understanding Centralization Risks in Web3

Some of the biggest threats to decentralization are centralized infrastructure, governance, and data. Many blockchains rely on a single company to maintain nodes and mining pools, creating a single point of failure. 

Centralized governance, where a small group makes decisions, goes against the democratic ideals of web3 and can lead to stagnation or cooption. And when user data is concentrated in the hands of a few big companies, it undermines privacy and gives those companies too much power.

For a truly decentralized web, there is a need to design protocols that distribute infrastructure, governance, and data across diverse, independent groups. This means blockchain networks with mining pools and nodes run by many different actors, governance models that give a voice to all stakeholders, and data storage solutions that keep information under users’ control.

Assessing a Protocol’s Current Level of Decentralization

You need to assess its key attributes to determine how decentralized a protocol is.

First, evaluate how dispersed control and decision-making are. Are changes made by a single entity or through consensus of many distributed nodes? The more spread out governance is, the better.

Next, look at how resistant the system is to manipulation or takeover. If one person or group can easily gain majority control or influence, that’s a red flag. Robust protocols make it difficult for any one party to dominate.

Also, consider how secure and tamper-proof data and transactions are. Information should be encrypted and distributed across nodes so no single point of failure exists.

Finally, assess how open and permissionless your network is. The lower the barriers to entry, the more decentralized. Anyone should be able to join anonymously and contribute resources.

If the protocol scores well on all these factors – dispersed governance, resistance to manipulation, secure and distributed data, and open access – it is on the road to true decentralization. 

By focusing on incentives, governance, infrastructure, and user experience, decentralization can be embedded into the DNA of the protocols. True decentralization may come with more work upfront, but the rewards pay off in the long run. While the decentralized web will take time to materialize, every little step brings us one step closer to a time when technology is equitable, open, and serves the interests of all.

Image Source: Adobe Stock

Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only. It is not offered or intended to be used as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.